Property Law Basics
Property law is a foundational pillar of the common law tradition, governing the relationships between individuals and between individuals and things. It defines rights and obligations concerning the ownership, use, and transfer of resources.
This guide covers estates in land, future interests, adverse possession, landlord-tenant law, and the Rule Against Perpetuities.
1Introduction
Property law is a foundational pillar of the common law tradition, governing the relationships between individuals and between individuals and things. At its core, property law is less about the "thing" itself and more about the rights one has with respect to that thing—often conceptualized as a "bundle of sticks," where each stick represents a distinct right (e.g., the right to possess, use, exclude, transfer, destroy).
Property is not a single thing but a collection of rights. Think of ownership as a bundle of sticks—you can give away some sticks (like the right to use) while keeping others (like the right to exclude).
2Key Definitions
Real Property
Land and anything permanently affixed to it (buildings, trees).
Personal Property
All property that is not real (tangible or intangible).
Estate in Land
Present possessory interest in land measured by duration.
Adverse Possession
Acquiring title by possessing property actual, open, notorious, hostile, exclusive, and continuous.
3Possession and Ownership
First Possession: Capture
Pierson v. Post [1805] established that ownership of wild animals requires physical possession (control or mortal wounding), not mere pursuit.
Finders' Rights
Lost Property
Finder has rights superior to all but true owner.
Mislaid Property
Locus in quo owner has rights to hold for true owner.
Abandoned Property
Finder acquires full title.
Treasure Trove
Gold/silver concealed long ago; finder may have rights.
4Estates in Land
Freehold Estates
Fee Simple Absolute
- Largest estate in land
- Potentially infinite duration
- Words: "To A and her heirs"
Fee Simple Determinable
- Automatically terminates
- Words: "So long as," "while"
- Future interest: Possibility of Reverter
Fee Simple Condition Subsequent
- May be terminated at grantor's election
- Words: "But if," "provided that"
- Future interest: Right of Entry
Life Estate
- Measured by lifetime of a person
- Words: "To A for life"
- Doctrine of Waste applies
5Future Interests
Future interests are non-possessory interests that grant the right to possess property at some point in the future.
Rule Against Perpetuities
"No interest is good unless it must vest, if at all, not later than 21 years after some life in being at the creation of the interest."
Subject to RAP: Contingent Remainders, Executory Interests, Options
NOT Subject to RAP: Reversions, Possibilities of Reverter, Rights of Entry, Vested Remainders
6Landlord-Tenant Law
Term of Years
Fixed, ascertainable period. Terminates automatically.
Periodic Tenancy
Successive periods until proper notice given.
Tenancy at Will
No fixed period, terminable by either party.
Tenancy at Sufferance
Holdover tenant after lease expires.
7Memory Aids
""Possess, Use, Exclude, Transfer, Destroy" — the rights that make up property ownership."
""So long as/while/until" = Determinable; "But if/Provided that" = Condition Subsequent."
""Fertile Octogenarian, Unborn Widow, Sloppy Scrivener" — common traps in RAP analysis."
""A-O-N-H-E-C" — Actual, Open, Notorious, Hostile, Exclusive, Continuous."
8Common Mistakes
A Fee Simple Determinable automatically reverts. A Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent requires affirmative action by the grantor to reclaim.
Reversions, Possibilities of Reverter, Rights of Entry, and Vested Remainders are NOT subject to the Rule Against Perpetuities.
Hostile in adverse possession means 'without permission,' not 'aggressive' or 'malicious.'
Contingent remainders have unascertained remaindermen or conditions precedent. Vested remainders have ascertained remaindermen with no conditions.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is the difference between real property and personal property?
- Real property includes land and anything permanently affixed to it (buildings, trees). Personal property includes all property that is not real property, including tangible items (cars, books) and intangible items (stocks, patents).
- What are the requirements for Adverse Possession?
- Adverse possession requires: actual (physical possession), open and notorious (visible to anyone), hostile (without permission), exclusive (not shared), and continuous for the statutory period (varies by jurisdiction).
- What is the difference between a Fee Simple Determinable and a Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent?
- A Fee Simple Determinable automatically terminates upon the occurrence of the stated event, with the grantor retaining a Possibility of Reverter. A Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent does not automatically terminate; the grantor must take affirmative action to reclaim the property, retaining a Right of Entry.
- What is the Rule Against Perpetuities?
- The Rule Against Perpetuities states that no interest is good unless it must vest, if at all, not later than 21 years after some life in being at the creation of the interest. It prevents property from being tied up indefinitely.
- What is the difference between a vested remainder and a contingent remainder?
- A vested remainder is created in an ascertained person and is not subject to any condition precedent. A contingent remainder is created in an unascertained person or is subject to a condition precedent.
- What are the different types of leasehold estates?
- The types include: Term of Years (fixed, ascertainable period), Periodic Tenancy (successive periods until proper notice), Tenancy at Will (no fixed period, terminable by either party), and Tenancy at Sufferance (holdover tenant).
Practice Quiz
Test your understanding — select the correct answer for each question.
1.Under the 'bundle of sticks' metaphor of property, which of the following represents a 'stick' in the bundle?
2.Which case established that 'possession' of a wild animal requires physical control or mortal wounding?
3.A grant 'to A so long as the land is used for a school' creates what type of estate?
4.What future interest does a grantor retain when creating a Fee Simple Determinable?
5.Which of the following is an example of a contingent remainder?
6.Under the Rule Against Perpetuities, which of the following interests is NOT subject to the rule?
7.A tenant remains in possession after the lease expires. What is this called?
8.What is the standard for acquiring title through Adverse Possession?
9.An easement where the holder has the right to use the land for a specific purpose is known as:
10.The 'discovery doctrine' established in *Johnson v. M'Intosh* primarily dealt with:
Study Tips
- Master estates first: Understanding fee simple, life estates, and leaseholds is foundational.
- Know the key cases: Pierson v. Post (wild animals), Johnson v. M'Intosh (discovery doctrine).
- Use memory aids: The 'bundle of sticks' and RAP mnemonics are essential.
- Practice future interests: Map out conveyances and identify all interests created.